Early Minnesota Twins Speculation

Willians Astudillo, February 16, 2019 - photo credit Bryan Green on Flickr

One thing that I like to do when looking at and evaluating prospects is to forecast opportunity. I like to look ahead at who could be blocking a prospect’s opportunity for promotion, whether it’s in the big leagues or in a different level within the minor league system. I think it’s important to do because it gives perspective into some long term thinking from the side of management as to when a player’s major league playing time could realistically begin. With that in mind I thought I’d look at the Minnesota Twins and give some early projections into playing time going into next season.


Mitch Garver: #1 catcher

Jason Castro: Free Agent

Willians Astudillo: Bench

What this means: Castro will probably go elsewhere, meaning there could be a competition for the backup spot. That said, Ryan Jeffers and Ben Rortvedt are both not ready for a big league promotion.

First Base:

C.J. Cron: Third year arbitration

What this means: The Twins have some decisions to make here at 1B. Do they move Sano over to 1B and let Cron walk? Do they sign a UFA? I believe their long term plan is to test Alex Kirilloff at 1B to start 2020 in the minors and see how that goes. If he adjusts nicely, they can ease him into that role for the second half of 2020. Having 1B eligibility is a nice bonus to have for Kirilloff owners.

Second Base:

Jonathan Schoop: Free Agent

What this means: There’s no guarantee that Schoop comes back. If he does, he will likely start the year at 2B. Having that probably means that Luis Arraez continues his role of shuffling himself around a few positions, all while leading off. One situation that could arise is giving Arraez the full-time gig, utilizing someone like Marwin Gonzalez as well to play everywhere, and then giving someone like Nick Gordon a shot to sit on the bench and get some opportunities. However, this is a small chance situation in my opinion, as Gordon, despite making progress, is losing time and chances to prove his worth.


Jorge Polanco: Starting SS

What this means: After the amazing season Polanco had as their starting shortstop, there’s no need for the Twins to rush anyone up to the big leagues. Royce Lewis is your next in line for 2021, at the earliest.

Third Base:

Miguel Sano: Second year arbitration

Sano seemed to right the ship after a deep demotion to get things to where they should be. As I mentioned above, the Twins have a big decision to make about their infield this season that could have minor league ramifications. There are no impactful corner infield minor league bats ready to help the Minnesota Twins in 2020.


Byron Buxton: Starting CF

Max Kepler: Starting RF

Eddie Rosario: Starting LF

What this means: The starting OF is all but set in stone. Nobody there is fearful of losing their jobs. However, the reserves are not close to being set. LaMonte Wade Jr played better than his stats would indicate, Ian Miller is no guarantee to make the big league club and Ryan LaMarre probably finds himself on another team. That means either free agency or a look to their minor league system, which is ripe with players ready to go. If Kirilloff doesn’t end up at 1B, look for him to get the call after a month or so. You know my feelings on him, he’s a top prospect ready to impress. Keep an eye on Brent Rooker too, who has some pop in his bat. Finally a dark horse would be Luke Raley, but he’s not as talented as the ones stated above. Any of those could speed up a Travis Blankenhorn promotion to AAA.

Designated Hitter:

Nelson Cruz

What this means: Like a fine wine……..


Jose Berrios: SP1

Kyle Gibson: Free Agent

Martin Perez: Team Option in 2020

Michael Pineda: Suspended

Devin Smeltzer: SP4

Brusdar Graterol: SP???

Randy Dobnak: SP???

Jake Odorizzi: Free Agent

Sean Poppen: Injury to end year

What this means: As you can see by the many names above, the Twins altered their starting rotation many times and went with a lot of names. It’ll depend on how the Twins feel after being dominated again by the Yankees. Do they look at this year as a stepping stone and be happy with their progress, keeping things status quo? Or do they feel like they need to make a major move to change the end result? Berrios is a lock to start. Jake Odorizzi had a career year and will look to be paid. Since the Twins are probably OUT on big name free agent pitchers, Odorizzi will likely stay. Smeltzer did well upon his call up, as did Dobnak. Martin Perez, after his suspension, will probably have to find a new home. I could see the Twins moving on from Gibson too. My prospective fantasy perspective is to keep an eye on the final two spots in the rotation. Dobnak, Graterol and Smeltzer will likely be fighting for 1-2 spots combined. However, the takeaway from this should be that all 3 have back end rotation potential for 2020. Finally, closely monitor Stephen Gonsalves as he returns from a major injury in 2019.


Tyler Duffey: Arbitration eligible

Zack Littell: Bullpen

Trevor May: Bullpen

Taylor Rogers: Second year arbitration, closer

Sergio Romo: Free agent

Cody Stashak: Bullpen

What this means: Do they stick with what they have and make minor additions? Do they go after another closer who is a righty instead of Rogers? I think the Twins stick with what worked for them. Their bullpen was solid for most of the season. I could see the “losers” of the Dobnak/Graterol/Smeltzer SP trio getting time to pitch in the bullpen, but there doesn’t seem to be many changes on the horizon. Romo was a half year piece for them that can be replaced. Watch for Fernando Romero to put things together and get a legitimate shot. Another round of Lewis Thorpe at Rochester could elevate his stock going forward too.

I realize that it is early in the game to fully predict the changes that the Twins might make, but it’s fun and informative to speculate on what could happen, all while keeping an eye on minor league promotions and moves. The biggest mover and shaker within their system is Kirilloff for reasons stated above, while the back end of their rotation will be the most interesting competition.

Dave Funnell covers the Minnesota Twins minor leagues for Prospects1500. Located just south of Toronto in the city of Hamilton, he's an hour away from Buffalo (and the Bisons). He's been a fan of baseball his entire life and doesn't have a favorite team, which hopefully gives way for objectivty in analysis. Dave is in multiple keeper fantasy baseball leagues and is active on Twitter at @sportz_nutt51.

1 Comment

  1. I believe Gonsalves was claimed by another team before this article was written. I’d like to see the Twins shore up their infield defense by moving Sano to first, letting Cron walk, move Polanco to 2B and try Gordon or Adrianza there regularly and let Gonzalez play 3B. Polanco is not a SS but looks like he could play 2B. Arraez looks like a great hitter but is a defensive liability. I’d consider resigning Castro as a backup since he’s likely to be a better value than any other FA. I wonder if the Twins would ever move Rosario to 2B. That’s where he started but I think he wasn’t that good defensively. I’d like to see the Twins sign a decent FA SP (Keuchel, Wheeler, maybe Roark) and resign Pineda who I think was rounding into form and can be gotten for a reasonable figure. Resigning Romo sounds good to me as well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.